Blue Ray Questions

1 reply [Last post]
f13ticket
Offline
Joined: 12/30/2009

I have some questions about Blue Ray.

1: Why does no one sue the entertainment industry for monopolistic practices? While it seems a long shot that the United States today will side with the people and their freedoms over the despotic control of the entertainment autocracy; there is the slim chance that something might be done. Also, and perhaps more important, our cause would be made on a level that might reach national and international news. As such, it might create a useful media circus that would prompt more activism on the issue. How could anyone see this situation as supporting a free market? There is a decisive, concerted effort by the mainstream entertainment industry to restrict the free access of technology to the people. This, not sharing, should be the felony.

2: How easy is it to side-step and ignore the encryption on Blue Ray and just play the disc anyone like it is possible to do with DVD? From what I understand, the early Blue Ray discs can be played but not the new ones? Is this accurate? Is there any hopeful signs of all Blue Ray discs being usable to us anytime soon?

3: Are we able to write to Blue Ray discs? From what I understand, and I could be wrong here, but reading a commercial disk and writing to a writable one is two different things as the writable one would not have the encryption. I don't see an option in Brasero for this. Is it in the works, or is some other program capable of this? I realize that at the moment that Blue Ray discs are not yet a popular burning standard. However, that might change in the future and I'm wondering if we are capable of this yet and if not how close we might be.

Thank GNU

quidam

I am a member!

I am a translator!

Offline
Joined: 12/22/2004

> 1: Why does no one sue the entertainment industry for monopolistic
> practices?

Can you explain what you mean first?

> 2: How easy is it to side-step and ignore the encryption on Blue Ray
> and just play the disc anyone like it is possible to do with DVD?

From a theoretical point of view, easy. Both DVD and HDDVD/Bluray
security systems are weak, but they are also complex. I mean, they
include many layers but none of them is hard to break. You can read
about the current progress in many places like this:
https://help.ubuntu.com/community/RestrictedFormats/BluRayAndHDDVD

From a legal point of view, a program designed to gain access to a DRM
crippled support is theoretically illegal under the WIPO treaty
(implemented via the DMCA law in the US and the EUCD in Europe).

> 3: Are we able to write to Blue Ray discs?

As with DVD's, this has nothing to do with DRM (which is implemented
via the disc data, the player and the drive working together), and the
technical process is mostly the same as ever. Although there are still
no graphical tools by now, you can do it in Trisquel using this:

growisofs -Z /dev/dvdrw -R -J /some/files
growisofs -speed=2 -dvd-compat -Z /dev/dvdrw=dvd_image.iso
_______________________________________________
Trisquel-users mailing list
name at domain
http://listas.trisquel.info/mailman/listinfo/trisquel-users